Tesla Stockholder's Case vs Musk's $56-B Pay Goes To Trial

As Elon Musk is engulfed in his overhaul of Twitter, the entrepreneur is headed to trial to defend his record $56 billion Tesla Inc. pay package against claims it unjustly enriches him without requiring his full-time presence at the carmaker, Tom Hals and Hyunjoo Jin reported for Reuters.

Photo Insert: Tornetta's lawyers argue the 2018 package failed its stated purpose of focusing Musk on Tesla.

A Tesla shareholder is seeking to rescind Musk's 2018 pay deal, claiming the board set easy performance targets and that Musk created the package to fund his dream of colonizing Mars.

Tesla has countered that the package delivered an extraordinary 10-fold increase in value to shareholders. The disputed pay package allows Musk to buy 1% of Tesla's stock at a deep discount each time escalating performance and financial targets are met, otherwise Musk gets nothing.

Tesla has hit 11 of the 12 targets as its value ballooned to $650 billion from $50 billion on the back of ramped up Model 3 production, according to court papers. Musk's vested grants are worth around $50 billion, according to Amit Batish at Equilar, an executive pay research firm.

The grants contribute to his $200-billion fortune, the world's largest. Musk's package of stock grants is larger than the combined pay of the 200 highest-paid CEOs last year - six times over, according to Batish.

The trial begins Nov. 14 and will be decided by Kathaleen McCormick on Delaware's Court of Chancery.

She oversaw Twitter's lawsuit against Musk that ended last month when he agreed to close his $44-billion deal for Twitter, an acquisition which he financed largely with his Tesla stock.

"If Musk loses this pay package in some massive way, I think we can expect to see a lot of things that are going to be really hard to predict, like what happens going forward in terms of how Tesla is run and how Twitter is paid for," said Ann Lipton, a professor at Tulane Law School.

Lipton and other legal experts said the lawsuit by Tesla shareholder Richard Tornetta is going to be much more difficult than Twitter's case against Musk.

Musk founded and is CEO of SpaceX, one of the world's most valuable private companies, and founded or co-founded Neuralink, which makes brain implants, tunneling venture The Boring Co, and OpenAI, an artificial intelligence research lab. Last week, he appointed himself Twitter CEO.

Tornetta's lawyers argue the 2018 package failed its stated purpose of focusing Musk on Tesla. They portray Musk as a "part-time CEO," citing his testimony that in 2018 he worked Tuesday, Wednesday and Friday at the electric carmaker and Monday and Thursday at rocket company SpaceX, according to his deposition.

WEEKLY FEATURE : MVP Group Keeps Lights On During Pandemic